In the Express Lane: Learning the Cello as an Adult
|www.ethanwiner.com - since 1997
In the Express Lane:
Learning the Cello as an Adult
by Ethan Winer - written in 1997
I began playing the cello at the age of 43, and at the time
considered myself fortunate to undertake this admittedly large project as an adult. As an
adult I didn't have to contend with the trauma of outgrowing an instrument. I'd also
played other instruments (electric guitar, Fender bass, some piano), and already
understood how music "works." Perhaps most important, I had a determination to
succeed that few children possess.
But starting as an adult also has unique drawbacks. Playing endless
variations of "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star" is hardly interesting to someone
who's studied musical scores and performed publicly. Worse, I knew how good music is
supposed to be played, and my early efforts were not even close. Beginner children don't
know how bad they sound, and thus are not so easily discouraged! Having played blues lead
guitar for many years I knew what it felt like to be in control of an instrument - to play
with feeling and conviction. I really hated being demoted to mediocre status as a beginner
on the cello, and wanted to get past that phase as quickly as possible. What I hoped would
be an enjoyable pastime soon evolved into an obsession to become proficient as quickly as
possible that now occupies three or four hours of each day.
In the five years since I began playing the cello I've made a number
of observations that I believe other adult beginners and intermediate players - especially
those who are ambitious and are willing to work hard - will find useful. Like Sergeant Joe
Friday on the TV show Dragnet, I have always been a seeker of "just the facts."
I'm not interested in guesses, half-baked opinions, or anything that can't be
substantiated. The facts I wanted to know are 1) What skills are needed to become an
accomplished cellist, and 2) How do I get there in the shortest amount of time?
In a previous career I owned a software company, and wrote books and
magazine articles about computer programming. Being a successful programmer requires
knowing the facts, and learning to play an instrument really is no different. However, to
become a proficient player requires learning the facts and also developing the
necessary mechanical skills. A good musician possesses "fine motor control" as
well as the artistic sense to know how to apply that control.
I'm convinced that what is often mistaken for musical talent or
aptitude is really persistence and enough belief in one's self to keep at it. It takes
thousands of practice hours to achieve competence and even more to become truly polished.
Unfortunately, many people give up long before then, mistakenly believing they don't have
the needed ability. But like walking and talking, most of the skills necessary for playing
an instrument are purely mechanical and can be developed by anyone given enough time. How
one actually applies that mechanical, muscular control is what distinguishes the truly
talented from the merely competent.
WHAT YOUR TEACHER WON'T TELL YOU
Most of my studying has been with one teacher, to whom I remain
devoted. But I've also taken single lessons from a number of other teachers, to get
additional opinions and to hear as many different viewpoints as possible. The more my
understanding of the cello has grown, the more surprised I am that few of these teachers
addressed certain mechanical aspects of playing the cello - in particular, the importance
and difficulty of the bow.
Many professional cellists and teachers achieve a beautiful tone,
yet cannot describe what it is they do physically to get that tone. I've been told,
"Draw the sound out, don't push it inward," which conveys no information and
provides no guidance for how to do that! Likewise, comments such as "Make a big
sound" and "Play with more resonance" are equally useless. Resonance is a
physical property (a propensity to vibrate), not something that a player controls. And a
good cellist can make a "big sound" even when playing very softly. In the
pursuit of a beautiful tone, bowing is the single most important skill to master. Bowing
is the cello's voice, and everything else revolves around that.
Bowing an instrument is an inherently awkward act. It is easy for a
teacher who has been playing since an early age to overlook the amount of strength and
control needed just to draw the bow smoothly. What happens in the first few milliseconds
of a note has an enormous bearing on the perceived character of the entire note. A
scratchy tone or flat pitch caused by too fast or too slow a bow speed - even if corrected
quickly - will make the entire note or passage sound amateurish. Controlling a bow and
changing its direction are some of the most difficult things to master, yet smooth bow
changes are fundamental to playing the cello. Until you can change bow direction without
making a scratching sound, every note you play will sound lame. If you listen to a
recording of any great cellist playing a slow passage you will note that every bow change
is flawless and beautiful - all you hear at each note transition is the slightest dip in
Note initiations can be sudden with a biting effect, or they can be
gentle followed by a gradual increase in volume. But a biting start should never be
distorted or scratchy. Cello strings are thick and heavy, and it takes a lot of strength
to get them moving. But pressing even a little too hard or drawing the bow even a little
too fast ruins the sound. Even more difficult is changing bow direction while also
changing the bow to a different string. These are the things a beginner must focus on the
most to overcome sounding like a beginner.
Another obstacle is developing an independence of the left and right
arms and hands. Not unlike the joke about walking and chewing gum at the same time, it is
harder to move your left hand accurately on the fingerboard while also changing the bow
direction. I've theorized that the brain splits its concentration between the two hands,
making it harder to control the bow and the left hand fingers at the same time. There are
difficult passages I can play confidently and in tune using pizzicato, but that are weak
and out of tune when played with the bow. Likewise, I can do a smoother bow change if I
first stop the vibrato. I know in time bowing will become automatic, and at that point
I'll work at continuing vibrato up to the exact moment when a new note begins.
Finally, many teachers stress that you should remain relaxed when
you play. But how can you possibly relax as you approach a passage you know you have only
a small chance of playing well? The fact is you can't! By all means try to relax - in my
case I tend to grip the bow too tightly in a vain effort to gain control - but also accept
that you won't become fully comfortable until you've been playing for many years.
PRACTICE SMARTER, NOT HARDER
I won't dispute the value of conventional learning methods -
studying etude books and progressively more difficult student pieces - but I'm convinced
there's an even faster way to become a competent cellist. It's been said that a month of
on-the-job training is equal to a year of college. By extension, you will progress faster
by working on real pieces rather than etudes and student compositions. Further, if you
practice etudes for three years, all you have to show for your effort is, well, etudes.
However, if you start now on a real concerto or sonata, you'll have learned and be able to
play a beautiful and meaningful piece of music for the same amount of effort. But you also
need to develop mechanical facility.
My practice hours are divided about equally between works from the
standard cello literature and highly focused mechanical exercises. It is these exercises
that I want to share here, and I'm convinced they are more useful than an etude book for a
motivated adult student. I have practiced these exercises daily for five years now, and I
can attest that they work and work well. By focusing directly on the most difficult
mechanical aspects of cello playing, you can reduce what might otherwise take ten or more
years to substantially less than that. After mastering the mechanics you can then work on
the more artistic aspects of this noble craft.
In the pursuit of a clear tone, the Number One issue is achieving
the ideal ratio of these three interrelated factors: bow speed, bow pressure, and bow
distance from the bridge. As the bow is drawn faster, more pressure is required to
maintain the optimum amount of friction. It is this optimum friction that makes for a
"big" sound. Cellists sometimes use less bow pressure or more speed to get a
beautiful silky tone, which can be enhanced by placing the bow farther from the bridge. A
special effect called Sul Ponticello uses a similar technique with the bow placed very
close to the bridge. But first you must develop the bow control needed to create a clear
tone - what I call a "pure buzz."
If the bow moves too fast at the start of a note it creates a
scratching sound; on sustained notes too much speed or too little pressure makes the bow
skate over the string instead of digging into it. When the bow speed is too slow or the
pressure is too great the note becomes distorted, or even flat in pitch. Likewise, when
the bow is nearer to the bridge more pressure is needed or, alternatively, the bow must be
drawn more slowly. This is especially apparent when playing fast passages on the lower
strings when changing bow direction for each note. Different notes - even on the same
string - also have a different optimum speed for a given amount of pressure. As you play
the short example in Figure 1 (all on the G string), notice how difficult it is to prevent
a brief scratching sound as each new note begins.
Achieving the optimum ratio of speed and pressure is hardest when
bowing near to the bridge, due to the very slow speed needed to sound a clear tone. It's
hard to keep such a slow speed steady. Yet this is where a soloist must play during loud
passages, to rise above the rest of the orchestra. It is harder still to bow slowly very
near the frog end.
I practice three similar exercises to develop the control needed to
smoothly change bow direction and maintain a pure tone during slow passages. The first
exercise is simply drawing the bow back and forth on each string twenty times, trying to
avoid a scratching sound when the bow changes direction. The scratching is caused by the
bow traveling too quickly, and these exercises force you to work at reducing the speed.
Place the bow within an inch of the bridge and an inch from the frog, and draw about two
inches of bow in each direction keeping the bow in contact with the string at all times.
The other two exercises shown in Figures 2a and 2b are variations that help develop smooth
bow crossings. Do each of these exercises as cleanly as possible on each string pair
bowing near the frog, starting both down- and up-bow, at least 20 times every day.
Equally valuable is practicing slow scales, always drawing the bow
fully from one end to the other. It is tempting to avoid the last few inches at each end
of the bow, but I urge you not to. If something is hard to do or uncomfortable, that's a
sure sign you need to practice it! Again, try to achieve a pure buzz, with no scuffing
sound when the bow direction changes. Also practice drawing the bow on each string as
slowly as possible, sustaining a single bow in each direction for at least 30 seconds or
longer and as smoothly as possible. This is easiest to do when the bow is farther away
from the bridge. Baseball players develop strength and control by swinging two bats at
once. In a similar manner, trying to bow more slowly than you'll ever really need
expedites developing a steady bow arm. The secret of making a powerful tone at low volumes
is keeping the bow very steady. It is the slight fluctuations in bow speed and pressure
that make a note sound wimpy, like it's played by a beginner.
Another useful exercise is what I call "touch downs,"
which help develop the ability to drop the bow onto a string without it bouncing. This is
especially difficult to do near the tip of the bow. Starting at the frog end of the bow
about a half inch above the C string, lower the bow slowly and carefully, draw one inch of
bow, raise it, back up a half inch, and repeat until you have reached the tip. Do that
once again working toward the frog, and then repeat on the other strings. (I joke to my
friends that I spend half my practice time trying to keep the bow from bouncing when I
don't want it to, and the other half trying to get it to bounce when it won't.)
Also valuable are what I think of as the bowing equivalents to
tongue twisters - exercises that for one reason or another are more difficult than they
might appear on a printed page. Changing the bow direction while also going to a different
string is more difficult than staying on the same string. By focusing on bowing exercises
that demand this movement you will practice the needed moves more often than they would
occur in a normal piece or etude. These are shown in Figures 3a through 3e.
I spend a few minutes every day on each of these exercises, going as
slowly as necessary to sound each note clearly and not accidentally hit two strings at
once. Then I do them again as fast as possible, ignoring that the bow doesn't dig
optimally into the strings, to get my hands used to "making the motions" quickly
and smoothly. Do the exercises in Figures 3d and 3e starting both down- and up-bow, and
also on every string-pair.
The exercises in 4a and 4b are also harder to play than they look
because the fingering itself is tricky. Figure 4c is a real challenge to play in tune
because it leads with the fourth finger descending instead of the first finger which is
more usual. Push yourself to play these as quickly as possible, but without making a
jumble of the notes.
Besides the difficulty of mastering string crossings, it is a
challenge just to coordinate bowing and fingering. The tried and true exercises in Figures
5a and 5b will be useful to players at any skill level; you can never play them fast
enough or cleanly enough. Again, do them starting both down- and up-bow, and first slowly
and then quickly. Also do the exercise in Figure 5a in the key of D (a whole step higher)
to get your left hand fingers used to the large stretches needed to play in that key in
Bowing is important, but so are smooth position shifts. The exercise
in Figure 6 is meant to be played all on the G string, but you should also repeat it on
the other strings. At each shift point try to make the shift as smoothly as possible -
never sudden or jerky. If you're not sure how to shift positions smoothly ask your teacher
to show you. There's a special way to do that which is not necessarily obvious. Go up and
down each string at least eight times, and you'll be amazed at how soon you are
comfortable playing near the very top of the fingerboard.
I also urge you to explore thumb position if you haven't already,
and practice scales and arpeggios daily that extend to the highest positions on the neck.
Playing a four-octave arpeggio is not something you'll be able to do all of a sudden one
day "when you are good." You have to start sometime, so why not today? Go as
slowly as necessary to start, and don't be discouraged by how slowly you have to play to
stay in tune.
Finally, make up your own exercises based on pieces you find
difficult to play. There are many other bowing and fingering exercises not shown here that
I practice every day, and many were derived from one passage or another that I stumbled
over during the course of playing real pieces. For example, when I had trouble playing
this phrase from the Dvorak Concerto (Figure 7):
I made up the exercise shown in Figure 8 and added it to my daily
For an additional challenge, use the second left hand finger instead
of the third for the high note in the middle of each figure. Then do it again using the
first finger each time for that high note. This exercise is especially useful because it
requires shifting repeatedly over the awkward area where the neck joins the body of the
Mechanical exercises are valuable because they focus on specific
aspects of cello technique. They are admittedly boring, but the work must be done.
However, exercises won't help you with sight reading, or further your understanding of
musical concepts. The best way to improve your reading skills is to keep working on new
pieces. Try to find a local orchestra to play with, or start a piano trio or string
quartet. It's difficult to find advanced players willing to practice with a beginner, but
at least try to find others who are as dedicated as you so you won't outgrow them. Many
towns have a community orchestra you can join even if you are not that advanced. Play the
passages you can, and rest or play softly during the hard parts. Or play only the first
note in each group of four sixteenth notes. Nobody will mind if you can't play everything
perfectly, as long as you don't wreck it for the others by playing out of tune too loudly.
Joining an amateur orchestra has the added benefit of sitting beside someone more
experienced who can show you fingerings and other techniques. After struggling for several
months to learn spiccato, a cellist in a local group showed me the basic moves in five
minutes during coffee break.
Equally valuable is attending concerts and watching video tapes. I
have most of the cello videos available, and I've learned something useful from every one
of them. The Shar catalog (800-248-SHAR) lists a number of videos - both teaching and
complete performances - and for about the cost of an hour-long lesson they're a good
value. I've also bought quite a few play-along tapes from Music Minus One (914-592-1188).
The only problem with accompaniment tapes is they're played at full tempo, which is often
too fast for a beginner. Also, minor variations in tape speed may require you to retune
your instrument for each tape. But nothing beats playing along with superb musicians who
get it right every time. I've also created my own accompaniments in my MIDI recording
studio, which has the advantage of letting me vary the playback tempo over a very wide
range without altering the pitch of the instruments.
If you watch an expert cellist playing a difficult piece, it is
tempting to think, "That must be very hard to do." But obviously it is not hard
for that cellist! I have a wise friend who once pointed out "It's only hard if you
can't do it." Becoming good enough to perform an advanced piece with ease is what's
difficult. Playing any instrument is a lifetime commitment, and the best cellists are
those who continue to practice their craft every day.
Ethan Winer lives in New Milford, Connecticut and at the time
this was written played the cello in the Danbury Symphony. He produced the "Cello
Master Class" videos featuring Bernard Greenhouse and has, at various times, earned a
living as a studio musician, computer programmer, audio engineer, composer/arranger, and
technical author. HIs video A Cello Rondo has received nearly two million views, though the
version linked here is a newer "high definition" render. Also see this interview
I did with Kyle at the Play Cello web site.
Entire contents of this web site Copyright �
1997- by Ethan Winer. All rights reserved.